# JH-042 · Worked responses for all eight prompts

These fictional review notes were written against `case-record.md`. They show what a reviewer can check in the text. They are neither a model transcript nor an agreement between the parties.

## R1. Compare vendor V1 against PB1

| Source | Vendor V1 | Buyer rule | Proposed first-round text |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| §4.1 | “within 15 calendar days of receipt” | PAY-01 asks for 30. Its conditional 20-day option has not been offered. | “Buyer will pay undisputed service invoices within 30 calendar days of receipt.” |
| §7.1 | “at least 90 calendar days before renewal” | REN-01 asks for 30. Ninety is outside the delegated position. | “The subscription renews for one year unless Buyer gives Vendor written notice of nonrenewal at least 30 calendar days before renewal.” |

## R2. Find a missing provision in V1

**DELIVERY-01 · Missing in the supplied §§4.1 and 7.1; full-document status unknown.** V1 requires written notice but the excerpt gives no delivery method. Ask Maya for the notices section and order form. If neither supplies the method, propose adding this sentence after §7.1: “Send notice by email to the notices address designated in the order form.” Verify that an address actually appears there. B1 asks the vendor for clarification before inserting text.

## C1. Draft the buyer's response to V2

**§7.1 · Counter.** Alder Relay now offers 60 days and specifies email delivery. Retain the proposed email sentence for verification under DELIVERY-01. Use the 30-day notice sentence from B1 under REN-01. Nothing in V2 gives the buyer authority to accept 60.

**§4.1 · Conditional draft.** PAY-01 supports the following internal proposal for review: “If §7.1 uses 30 calendar days' notice, Buyer can pay undisputed service invoices within 20 calendar days of receipt.” If the vendor keeps 60 days, retain B1's 30-day payment proposal. Do not disclose the unapproved 45-day fallback.

## C2. Triage the latest reply

| Recommendation | Source | Rule and next owner |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Counter the 60-day notice | V2 §7.1 | REN-01. Priya reviews the 30-day response. Hold any change to the 45-day alternative. |
| Keep the proposed email method subject to verification | V2 §7.1 | DELIVERY-01. Maya obtains the order form and checks the address and any inconsistent notice terms. |
| Discuss payment conditionally | V2 §4.1 and vendor message | PAY-01. The vendor proposed 20 days but has not agreed to 30 days' notice. Keep the terms linked for Priya's review. |

## F1. Lay out the notice fallback

1. **30 calendar days · Preferred.** REN-01 supports the B1 notice sentence. Carry it into the next internal draft.
2. **45 calendar days · Conditional exception.** Priya Shah must approve this exact period for JH-042 before anyone proposes it. No approval is recorded. Keep it internal.
3. **60 or 90 calendar days · Hold.** These vendor positions fall outside the delegated playbook. Refer them to Priya and keep the renewal issue open. No intermediate number has been authorized.

## F2. Evaluate one trade across clauses

**Give:** Move undisputed invoice payment from 30 to 20 days under PAY-01. **Get:** Retain 30 days' nonrenewal notice under REN-01. **Evidence:** V2 says the vendor will discuss shorter notice in exchange for faster payment. It does not say it accepts 30 days.

The internal conditional proposal is the sentence under C1. If the vendor holds at 60 or asks for 45, this trade lapses under PAY-01. Priya must review any different package and the separate 45-day exception before it is offered. Maya cannot release it by supplying the missing dates.

## P1. Describe the opening positions

V1 §7.1 sets 90 days against the buyer's 30-day target. Ask, “Would a shorter notice period work, and where should written notice be sent?” V1 §4.1 sets payment at 15 days against the buyer's 30-day target. Ask whether the timing is flexible. The excerpts supply no explanation for either position.

## P2. Compare the two rounds

| Term | Vendor V1 | Buyer B1 | Vendor V2 | Still open |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Nonrenewal notice | 90 days | 30 days | 60 days | Priya reviews the counter. A possible 45-day exception remains internal. |
| Invoice payment | 15 days | 30 days | 20 days | A 20-for-30 trade is possible under PAY-01. No exchange is agreed. |
| Notice delivery | Written notice, no channel in excerpts | Confirm method and location | Email to address designated in order form | Maya needs the order form and complete notice terms. |

**Decision log · Priya Shah · JH-042.** Next internal position: seek 30 days' notice. 45-day exception: pending, not offered. 60-day counter: not accepted. Delivery address: unverified. Release or signing: none. Retain the versions and refer the open issues to their owners.
